Fall 2018 - Problem 12

Rouché's theorem

If αC\alpha \in \C satisfies 0<α<10 < \abs{\alpha} < 1 and if nN={1,2,3,}n \in \N = \set{1, 2, 3, \ldots} show that the equation

ez(z1)n=αe^z\p{z - 1}^n = \alpha

has exactly nn simple roots int he half-plane {zRez>0}\set{z \mid \Re{z} > 0}.

Solution.

Consider the homotopy ft(z)=etz(z1)nf_t\p{z} = e^{tz} \p{z - 1}^n. Observe that on the circle z1=1\abs{z - 1} = 1, we have

ft(z)=etReze0=1>α,\abs{f_t\p{z}} = e^{t\Re{z}} \geq e^0 = 1 > \abs{\alpha},

so ft(z)αf_t\p{z} - \alpha never vanishes on this circle. Thus, by Cauchy's theorem, if γ\gamma is the curve z1=1\abs{z - 1} = 1, we get

12πiγft(z)ft(z)α=12πift(γ)dwwα\frac{1}{2\pi i} \int_\gamma \frac{f_t'\p{z}}{f_t\p{z} - \alpha} = \frac{1}{2\pi i} \int_{f_t\p{\gamma}} \frac{\diff{w}}{w - \alpha}

is a constant. When t=0t = 0, we get f0(z)=(z1)nf_0\p{z} = \p{z - 1}^n, so the integral is equal to nn, and by the argument principle, this means that ez(z1)n=αe^z\p{z - 1}^n = \alpha has precisely nn solutions in the interior of the circle z1=1\abs{z - 1} = 1.

To show that these solutions are simple, suppose ww is a solution to the equation. Then if f(z)=ez(z1)nf\p{z} = e^z\p{z - 1}^n, then

f(z)=ez(z1)n+nez(z1)n1    f(w)=α+nαw1.f'\p{z} = e^z\p{z - 1}^n + ne^z\p{z - 1}^{n-1} \implies f'\p{w} = \alpha + \frac{n\alpha}{w - 1}.

This is 00 if and only if

1+nw1=0    w=1n,1 + \frac{n}{w - 1} = 0 \implies w = 1 - n,

but Re(1n)0\Re\p{1 - n} \leq 0, but Rew>0\Re{w} > 0. Thus, any solution to the equation must be simple.