Fall 2010 - Problem 8

operator theory

Let A(D)A\p{\D} be the C\C-vector space of all holomorphic functions on D\D and suppose that L ⁣:A(D)C\func{L}{A\p{\D}}{\C} is a multiplicative linear functional, that is,

L(af+bg)=aL(f)+bL(g)andL(fg)=L(f)L(g)L\p{af + bg} = aL\p{f} + bL\p{g} \quad\text{and}\quad L\p{fg} = L\p{f}L\p{g}

for all a,bCa, b \in \C and all f,gA(D)f, g \in A\p{\D}. If LL is not identically zero, show that there is z0Dz_0 \in \D so that L(f)=f(z0)L\p{f} = f\p{z_0} for all fA(D)f \in A\p{\D}.

Solution.

Set z0=L(z)z_0 = L\p{z}. Since LL is not identically zero, there exists fA(D)f \in A\p{\D} such that L(f)0L\p{f} \neq 0. Thus, by multiplicity of LL, we have L(f1)=L(f)L(1)    L(1)=1L\p{f \cdot 1} = L\p{f}L\p{1} \implies L\p{1} = 1. Similarly, L(zn)=(L(z))n=z0nL\p{z^n} = \p{L\p{z}}^n = z_0^n, and so by linearity of LL, we have shown that the claim is true whenever ff is a polynomial.

Now let fA(D)f \in A\p{\D}. Since ff is holomorphic, we may apply the factor theorem to get f(z)f(z0)=(zz0)g(z)f\p{z} - f\p{z_0} = \p{z - z_0}g\p{z}. By multiplicity of LL, L(f(z)f(z0))=L(zz0)L(g(z))=0L\p{f\p{z} - f\p{z_0}} = L\p{z - z_0}L\p{g\p{z}} = 0. By linearity, we conclude that

L(f(z))=L(f(z0))=f(z0)L(1)=f(z0).L\p{f\p{z}} = L\p{f\p{z_0}} = f\p{z_0}L\p{1} = f\p{z_0}.

To complete the proof, we need to show that z0Dz_0 \in \D. If this were not the case, then f(z)=1zz0A(D)f\p{z} = \frac{1}{z - z_0} \in A\p{\D}, which implies that L(f(z))=f(z0)=CL\p{f\p{z}} = f\p{z_0} = \infty \in \C, but this is absurd.