Spring 2009 - Problem 10

mean value property, Morera's theorem

Let D\D be the open unit disc and μ\mu be the Lebesgue measure on D\D. Let HH be the subspace of L2(D,μ)L^2\p{\D, \mu} consisting of holomorphic functions. Show that HH is complete.

Solution.

L2(D,μ)L^2\p{\D, \mu} is itself complete, so it suffices to show that HH is closed in L2(D,μ)L^2\p{\D, \mu}.

Let {fn}nH\set{f_n}_n \subseteq H be a sequence converging to fL2(D,μ)f \in L^2\p{\D, \mu}. Let zDz \in \D and 0<r<R0 < r < R small enough so that B(z,R)D\cl{B\p{z, R}} \subseteq \D. Then by the mean value property,

fn(z)fm(z)=12π02πfn(z+reiθ)fm(z+reiθ)dz=12π02πfn(z+reiθ)fm(z+reiθ)dθ.\begin{aligned} f_n\p{z} - f_m\p{z} &= \frac{1}{2\pi} \int_0^{2\pi} f_n\p{z + re^{i\theta}} - f_m\p{z + re^{i\theta}} \,\diff{z} \\ &= \frac{1}{2\pi} \int_0^{2\pi} f_n\p{z + re^{i\theta}} - f_m\p{z + re^{i\theta}} \,\diff\theta. \end{aligned}

Multiplying both sides by 2r2r and integrating over [0,R]\br{0, R}, we get

2r(fn(z)fm(z))=1π02πr(fn(z+reiθ)fm(z+reiθ))dθ    R2(fn(z)fm(z))=1π02πfn(z)fm(z)dμ    fn(z)fm(z)=1πR2B(z,R)fn(z)fm(z)dμ.\begin{aligned} 2r\p{f_n\p{z} - f_m\p{z}} &= \frac{1}{\pi} \int_0^{2\pi} r\p{f_n\p{z + re^{i\theta}} - f_m\p{z + re^{i\theta}}} \,\diff\theta \\ \implies R^2\p{f_n\p{z} - f_m\p{z}} &= \frac{1}{\pi} \int_0^{2\pi} f_n\p{z} - f_m\p{z} \,\diff\mu \\ \implies f_n\p{z} - f_m\p{z} &= \frac{1}{\pi R^2} \int_{B\p{z,R}} f_n\p{z} - f_m\p{z} \,\diff\mu. \end{aligned}

Now we may apply the triangle inequality along with Cauchy-Schwarz:

fn(z)fm(z)1πR2B(z,R)fn(z)fm(z)dμ(μ(B(z,R)))1/2πR2fnfm2(μ(B(z,R)))1/2πR2fnfm2\begin{aligned} \abs{f_n\p{z} - f_m\p{z}} &\leq \frac{1}{\pi R^2} \int_{B\p{z,R}} \abs{f_n\p{z} - f_m\p{z}} \,\diff\mu \\ &\leq \frac{\p{\mu\p{B\p{z, R}}}^{1/2}}{\pi R^2} \norm{f_n - f_m}_2 \\ &\leq \frac{\p{\mu\p{B\p{z, R}}}^{1/2}}{\pi R^2} \norm{f_n - f_m}_2 \end{aligned}

We will show that {fn}n\set{f_n}_n is locally uniformly Cauchy: Let 0<R<10 < R < 1 and let 0<δ<dist(B(0,R),Dc)0 < \delta < \operatorname{dist}\p{\cl{B\p{0, R}}, \D^\comp}. This is positive since it is the distance between two closed, disjoint sets. Thus, for any zB(0,R)z \in B\p{0, R} we have that B(z,δ)B(0,R+δ)DB\p{z, \delta} \subseteq \cl{B\p{0, R + \delta}} \subseteq \D, and so

fn(z)fm(z)(μ(B(z,δ)))1/2πδ2fnfm2(μ(B(0,R)))1/2πδ2fnfm2=CRfnfm2,\begin{aligned} \abs{f_n\p{z} - f_m\p{z}} &\leq \frac{\p{\mu\p{B\p{z, \delta}}}^{1/2}}{\pi \delta^2} \norm{f_n - f_m}_2 \\ &\leq \frac{\p{\mu\p{B\p{0, R}}}^{1/2}}{\pi \delta^2} \norm{f_n - f_m}_2 \\ &= C_R \norm{f_n - f_m}_2, \end{aligned}

and notice that CRC_R is independent of zz. Thus, since {fn}n\set{f_n}_n is Cauchy in L2(D,μ)L^2\p{\D, \mu}, it follows that {fn}n\set{f_n}_n is uniformly Cauchy on B(0,R)\cl{B\p{0, R}}. Since RR was arbitrary, it follows that {fn}n\set{f_n}_n is uniformly Cauchy on any compact set, so by completeness, there exists g ⁣:DC\func{g}{\D}{\C} such that fnff_n \to f uniformly on compact sets.

By assumption, fnff_n \to f in L2(D,μ)L^2\p{\D, \mu}, so there exists a subsequence which converges pointwise to ff almost everywhere. Since fngf_n \to g pointwise, it follows that g=fg = f almost everywhere, so the pointwise limit is the same thing as the L2(D,μ)L^2\p{\D, \mu} limit.

Finally, since fnf_n is holomorphic, it is continuous, which means that ff is continuous as well. Hence, we may apply Morera's theorem. By uniform convergence on compact sets, we get for any square R\partial R in D\D that

0=limnRfn(z)dz=Rf(z)dz,0 = \lim_{n\to\infty} \int_{\partial R} f_n\p{z} \,\diff{z} = \int_{\partial R} f\p{z} \,\diff{z},

so fHf \in H. Consequently, HH is closed, hence complete.